Authenticity Guarantee

At Wickidie Picks, every autographed item we sell is authenticated by a recognized third-party authentication service before it reaches you. We do not sell unsigned items represented as signed, and we do not accept self-authenticated signatures.

How We Authenticate

We rely exclusively on established, industry-respected authentication services. Each service uses trained experts who examine signatures against extensive reference databases before issuing a certificate.

Beckett Authentication Services (BAS)

Beckett is one of the most recognized names in sports collectibles. Their authentication team examines signatures in person or through their mail-in service and issues a tamper-evident sticker with a unique serial number traceable at beckett.com/authentication. Items authenticated by Beckett carry a BAS sticker and, in many cases, a full certificate of authenticity (COA).

James Spence Authentication (JSA)

JSA is a leading third-party authenticator for autographed sports and entertainment memorabilia. Each authenticated item receives a JSA sticker or full letter of authenticity (LOA) with a serial number verifiable at jsa.cc.

Certificate of Authenticity (COA)

Some items include a COA issued directly by the signing event organizer, team, or a reputable dealer. Where a COA is the primary authentication document, we note the issuing source clearly in the product listing.

What to Expect With Your Purchase

Every autographed item listing specifies the authentication source (BAS, JSA, PSA, COA, or other).
The original authentication sticker or certificate ships with the item — we do not remove or alter authentication materials.
Serial numbers on stickers can be independently verified on the authenticator's website at any time.
Photos of the certificate or sticker are included in product listings wherever possible.

Our Guarantee

If you receive an item and have a genuine concern about its authenticity, contact us within 30 days of delivery. We will work with you to review the documentation. If an item cannot be verified as authentic through its stated authentication source, we will issue a full refund upon return of the item.

We stand behind every item we sell. Our reputation in the hobby depends on it.